2005
Best of Yahoo!- Best Pizza
San Francisco Magazine- Best Pizza
CitySearch.com- Best Pizza

2004
CitySearch.com- Best Pizza
Bay Area Parent Magazine: Family Favorite Award- Best Pizza

2003
San Mateo County Times Reader's Choice - Best Pizza
CitySearch.com- 3rd place, Best Pizza
Bay Area Parent Magazine: Family Favorite award- Best Pizza

2002
SF Weekly Reader's Choice - Best Pizza
San Mateo County Times Reader's Choice - Honorable Mention, Best Pizza
Best Pizza: Top 10 Audience Nominee and Top 10 Editorial Nominee by MSN/CitySearch.com

2001
San Mateo County Times Reader's Choice - Best Pizza
SF Weekly Reader's Choice - Best Pizza
Bay Area Parent Magazine "Best of the Best" Reader's Choice - Bronze Medal, Best Pizza

2000
San Francisco Chronicle Reader's Choice - 3rd Place, Best Pizza

1999
San Francisco Chronicle Reader's Choice - 2nd Place, Best Pizza

1998
The Best Restaurants in America "Where the Locals Eat" Reader's Choice - Best Pizza
San Mateo County Times Reader's Choice - Honorable Mention, Best Pizza
San Francisco Chronicle Reader's Choice - 2nd Place, Best Pizza

1997
SF Weekly Reader's Choice - Best Pizza
San Mateo County Times Reader's Choice - Best Pizza
Dine.Com - Best Pizza

1996
San Mateo County Times Reader's Choice - Best Pizza

1995
San Francisco Guardian "Best of the Bay" Readers Choice Poll

1994
San Francisco Guardian "Best of the Bay" Reader's Choice Poll - Best Pizza
San Mateo County Times Reader's Choice - Best Pizza
San Mateo Chamber of Commerce Taste of San Mateo "Tops of the Taste" - 3rd Place

1993
San Francisco Guardian "Best of the Bay" Reader's Choice Poll - Best Pizza

1984
San Francisco Fair & Exposition "Ultimate Pizza Judging 1st Place Gold Award"